An SEO proposal promises twenty new links a month. You ask where those links will appear, and the supplier answers with a domain-authority target. You still do not know what you are buying.
Before you approve link acquisition, ask the provider to describe the transaction: who owns the publishing site, why that publisher would mention your business, whether anyone receives payment, and whether the placement serves readers who might need your service.
Google identifies links created primarily to manipulate rankings as link spam. Its examples include paid ranking links, automated links, and low-quality directory links. Advertising and sponsorship links can comply when publishers qualify them with appropriate link attributes. See Google's current spam policies.
Three proposals, three different decisions
These hypothetical proposals illustrate how to review a method. They do not describe a particular supplier.
| Proposal | What the buyer should establish | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Pay a group of unrelated blogs for articles containing keyword-rich links that pass ranking credit. | Who receives payment, who controls the sites, and how the publisher treats the links. | Decline the ranking-link tactic. A paid editorial-looking placement does not become acceptable because the article contains your company name. |
| Pitch your original maintenance-cost guide to a trade publication whose readers operate the equipment you service. | Whether the publisher has editorial discretion and whether your guide supplies something readers can use. | Consider the outreach. Approve the work and the evidence asset; do not purchase a guaranteed editorial outcome. |
| Sponsor a relevant local event with a listing and website link. | Audience fit, actual sponsorship benefits, and qualification of the paid link. | Evaluate as sponsorship. Keep the commercial benefit separate from a promised search ranking. |
The middle proposal can still waste money. A relevant publication may decline the pitch, or its readers may have no reason to contact you. Policy compliance and commercial usefulness require separate judgments.
Ask for a sample you can inspect
Request three representative placements from the proposed method, with permission to share them. Open the pages. Read the surrounding article and check whether the link helps someone do something. A list of scores removes the context you need.
For a service business, relevance can mean a neighborhood resource, a professional association, a supplier's partner directory, or a useful trade article. The relevant relationship must exist. A business listing on a genuine directory differs from buying hundreds of low-quality listings for link volume.
Ask the supplier to complete this evidence request:
- Publisher: Name the site owner and explain why the audience fits our service.
- Placement: Show the expected page type and a representative example.
- Exchange: State any money, goods, reciprocal link, or other consideration involved.
- Control: Identify who approves the copy, anchor text, and outbound-link attributes.
- Acceptance: Describe what we pay for if an editor declines the pitch or a placement disappears.
Keep the approval narrow
Approve a defined activity rather than a monthly link quota. For the maintenance guide, that might mean producing a documented comparison, contacting a named set of relevant publishers, and reporting responses. The provider can deliver that work without controlling independent editors.
For sponsorship, specify the audience exposure and placement terms you value. If the supplier promises ranking credit from the paid link, ask them to revise the proposal before you buy.
Review the actual placements after delivery. A relevant pitch can turn into an unrelated site placement if the supplier substitutes inventory to meet a quota. Give your team authority to reject that substitution, and retain the placement evidence alongside the original approval.
Once you understand the method, use these questions for an SEO company to examine implementation and account ownership. For help reviewing the whole improvement plan, explore The Ops Guide's SEO services.

